Bay St. Louis MS Independent Insurance Agents

Home, flood and business coverage for Bay St. Louis, compared for you.
Hancock County · Mississippi Gulf Coast

Insurance for Bay St. Louis homes and businesses

Bay St. Louis is the Hancock County seat, known for its Old Town shops, galleries and beachfront. Gartman Insurance Agency helps Bay St. Louis homeowners and business owners compare coverage from many carriers.

We are an independent agency, so you get options and honest advice.

The Independent Advantage

Local agents and service
No-obligation quotes
Top-rated carriers
Licensed professionals
We work for you, not for one insurance company.
What We Cover

Coverage for Bay St. Louis families and businesses

Home Insurance

Homeowners, condo and renters coverage built around your home and your belongings.

Auto Insurance

Cars, trucks, motorcycles, boats and more, with top-rated carriers compared for you.

Flood Insurance

Homeowners policies don’t cover flood damage. We’ll help you add the protection.

Business Insurance

Liability, property, workers’ comp and commercial auto for businesses of every size.

Life Insurance

Term, whole and universal life to protect the people who count on you.

Umbrella Insurance

An extra layer of liability protection above your home and auto limits.
Local Knowledge

Old Town charm, coastal exposure

Historic cottages, elevated new construction and second homes each raise different coverage questions. We’ll review rebuilding costs, wind coverage and flood insurance, and if you rent your home to visitors, we’ll make sure your policy allows it.

Insurance Companies We Represent
Peace Of Mind

4 steps to better coverage

01

Connect

Tell us about you and what you want to protect.
02

Compare

We shop top-rated carriers to find your best fit.
03

Customize

Tailor coverage and limits to match your life or business.
04

Covered

Enjoy ongoing concierge service and peace of mind.
Common Questions

Insurance questions in Bay St. Louis

Straight answers to what local homeowners, drivers and business owners ask us most. Don’t see your question? Call us at (228) 872-3881 and we’ll talk it through.

Does an older cottage in Old Town cost more to insure?

It can. Carriers look at the age of the roof, wiring and plumbing, and at what it would cost to rebuild with similar materials. Updates help, so let us know what has been replaced. We’ll also check that your limit reflects true rebuilding cost.

I rent my home to vacationers. Do I need a different policy?

Probably. Many homeowners policies exclude or limit short-term rentals. A policy written for that use covers the building, your furnishings, your liability to guests and lost rental income after a covered loss.

My Bay St. Louis house is a second home. Does that change anything?

Yes. Carriers rate second homes differently, and some limit coverage when a home is unoccupied for a long stretch. Tell us how often you are there and whether someone checks on the house while you are away.

How do claims work when wind and flood damage the same home?

You file two claims, one on the wind coverage and one on the flood policy, and each pays for its own share of the damage. Photos of your home and belongings taken before the storm make it easier to sort out.

Ready When You Are

Insurance quotes for Bay St. Louis

Get a free, no-obligation quote. Our agents are ready to help.

Personalized Support

We listen to your needs and tailor our services to match, ensuring you receive the right coverage for your unique situation.

Competitive Rates

Our pricing structure is designed to be competitive, giving you the best value without compromising on service.

Trustworthy Advisors

Our knowledgeable agents provide insights and advice, helping you navigate your options with confidence.